Buffehr Lake is a hidden alpine gem tucked into the mountains of Summit County near the town of Vail, accessible only by foot on a short but steep hike that rewards visitors with one of the most photogenic lake settings in the Colorado Rockies. Sitting at approximately 10,400 feet of elevation, this small glacial lake is framed by towering cliffs, dense evergreen forest, and wildflower meadows that create a scene visitors describe as unlike anything else in the world.
The hike to Buffehr Lake starts from a trailhead near the Vail Valley and climbs steeply through switchbacks and forested terrain before opening up to the lake basin. The trail is roughly 3 miles round trip but gains significant elevation in a short distance, making it a moderately challenging outing despite its brevity. The steep grade means this hike packs a punch — expect to work on the way up, but the payoff at the top is immediate and spectacular. Most hikers complete the round trip in 2 to 3 hours, including time spent at the lake.
Buffehr Lake itself is small, clear, and stunningly set beneath dramatic rock walls. The surrounding alpine meadows fill with columbine, Indian paintbrush, and other wildflowers from late June through August, and the fall brings golden aspen groves along the lower portions of the trail. The lake is quiet and rarely crowded compared to more well-known destinations in the Vail area, making it a favorite of locals who want a mountain lake experience without the traffic of spots like Piney River Ranch or Booth Falls.
Fishing is possible at Buffehr Lake for those who carry gear up the trail. The lake holds small trout, and the limited access means fishing pressure is light. Fly fishing along the shoreline with small dry flies can produce action, especially in the calmer morning hours before afternoon winds pick up.
There are no facilities at Buffehr Lake — no restrooms, no picnic tables, no trash cans. This is a pack-in, pack-out destination that requires hikers to be self-sufficient. Bring plenty of water, snacks, and sun protection, as the lake basin is exposed and the hike is physically demanding. Afternoon thunderstorms are a regular occurrence above treeline in summer, so starting early in the morning is strongly recommended. The trailhead has limited parking, and on busy summer weekends spaces fill up quickly — arriving before 8 AM helps secure a spot.
Buffehr Lake is a seasonal destination, generally accessible from late June through early October depending on snowfall. When the snow melts and the wildflowers bloom, this lake becomes one of those Colorado experiences that stays with you long after the hike is over.