Totten Lake sits in the wide-open mesa country of Montezuma County, a quiet fishing spot that delivers what many anglers want most: big fish and few crowds. Located near the town of Cortez in the Four Corners region of southwestern Colorado, this lake draws visitors who appreciate its relaxed atmosphere and the chance to hook into sizable northern pike, largemouth bass, and channel catfish without fighting for shoreline space.
Fishing is the main draw at Totten Lake, and the catch reports speak for themselves. Northern pike are plentiful here, with anglers regularly pulling in impressive specimens from the deeper sections along the western shoreline. Largemouth bass patrol the shallower weedy areas, especially during early morning and late evening hours in summer. Channel catfish round out the warm-water fishery, with some visitors reporting big catfish taken on cut bait near the dam. The lake receives stocking support from Colorado Parks and Wildlife, helping to maintain healthy populations of all three primary species. Spring and early fall tend to produce the best fishing, though pike remain active into the colder months for anglers willing to brave the weather.
Shoreline access is available, though the trail does not extend around the entire perimeter of the lake. Plan to fish from the more accessible eastern and southern banks, or bring a small boat or float tube to reach the less pressured areas across the water. Motorized boats with low horsepower may be permitted, but many visitors prefer kayaks or canoes for navigating the calm surface. Basic vault toilets are on-site, though visitors note the restroom facilities could use maintenance. Parking is available near the access point, and the open terrain makes it straightforward to set up for a day of fishing or a picnic along the shore.
The surrounding landscape offers sweeping views of the mesa country and striking sunsets over the water, a bonus for anyone camping in the area or simply unwinding after an afternoon cast. Mosquitoes can be aggressive during warmer months, so pack repellent. Totten Lake is a solid choice for anglers targeting warm-water species in a part of Colorado where trout streams dominate the conversation. The Four Corners area also puts you within easy reach of Mesa Verde National Park, Hovenweep National Monument, and the desert canyon country of southeastern Utah, making Totten Lake a worthwhile stop on a broader southwestern Colorado trip.