Puett Reservoir is a 153-acre warm-water fishery managed by Colorado Parks and Wildlife as a State Wildlife Area in Montezuma County, Colorado. Situated about 10 miles north of the small town of Mancos along County Road P.2, this reservoir sits in the rolling mesa country between the La Plata Mountains and Mesa Verde, offering a rugged fishing destination for anglers willing to navigate the rural road network. With a 3.3-star rating from visitors, Puett Reservoir polarizes opinions -- some love the northern pike fishing, while others find the limited access and murky water frustrating.
Fishing is the sole reason most people visit Puett Reservoir, and northern pike are the headline species. Anglers report catching large pike here, making it one of the better pike fisheries in southwestern Colorado. Yellow perch, smallmouth bass, walleye, and panfish also inhabit the reservoir, giving anglers a warm-water species mix uncommon at this elevation. Water visibility is typically low, often around one foot, so lure selection and presentation matter. Bait fishing and slow retrieves with spinnerbaits or jerkbaits tend to produce when visibility is poor. Kayak fishing is an option, and the reservoir has a boat ramp for launching small watercraft.
Access rules at Puett Reservoir are strict. A valid Colorado fishing license, hunting license, or State Wildlife Area pass is required for anyone 16 or older just to enter the property. Fishing is prohibited on the dam and in posted restricted areas around the reservoir. Ice fishing is prohibited. Spearfishing, archery, and gigs are not allowed for northern pike. Shore access is limited, and visitors consistently note that there is little walkable shoreline, no shade, and no swimming allowed. This is a fishing-focused destination, not a picnicking or family recreation spot.
The State Wildlife Area designation also means that camping and fires are prohibited at Puett Reservoir. There are no restrooms, no potable water, and no amenities beyond the boat ramp and parking area. Visitors need to be fully self-sufficient. The nearest services are in Mancos, about 10 miles to the south along Highway 184.
Be aware of access directions. Some GPS and mapping apps route visitors through private property to reach the reservoir, which causes problems with landowners. The correct route runs from Highway 184 to County Road 33, then east on P.2 Road. Mosquitoes can be heavy during summer months, so bring repellent. Bird watchers will find the State Wildlife Area productive, as the reservoir and surrounding habitat attract waterfowl, raptors, and shorebirds. For current regulations on vessel launching and specific fishing rules, contact the Durango CPW office at 970-247-0855.