Lily Lake

Lily Lake in Huerfano County is a high-alpine destination tucked into the Sangre de Cristo Range, serving as both a fishing lake and a base camp for hikers heading up Mount Lindsey and surrounding 13,000-foot peaks. Reviewers consistently praise the crystal-clear water, the spectacular mountain views, and the relative quiet compared to more trafficked Front Range trailheads. The area feels remote and uncrowded, and several visitors describe it as one of Colorado's best-kept secrets.

The hike to Lily Lake is challenging. The trail starts easy but steepens significantly as you approach the lake, and reviewers recommend stretching beforehand and being prepared for a strenuous push. At the junction, bear right at the Lily Lake sign; going left leads toward the Mount Lindsey 14er route. Avalanche debris can cover portions of the trail in spring, slowing progress. Ridge routes offer scrambling for those seeking more technical terrain. Multiple hikers describe it as one of the harder day hikes they have done, but unanimously say the payoff is worth the effort.

Fishing at Lily Lake draws visitors who report good catches in clear water, even during May spring runoff. The lake sits in a pristine alpine setting that makes casting a line feel like a backcountry experience. Wildlife sightings are common along the approach and near the lake, including grouse, deer, elk, and bighorn sheep, making this a rewarding destination for nature watchers as well.

Dispersed camping lines the road leading to the trailhead, with several spots close to the start of the trail. The road is passable in 2WD when dry, though it narrows with low-hanging branches toward the end, and the upper trailhead access road requires 4WD. Google Maps directions can be unreliable here; approach through Gardner to avoid ending up at a locked gate on the opposite side. Narrow roads mean careful driving, but fellow visitors are described as friendly and helpful. Pack out all trash and fish remains, as some reviewers have noted irresponsible waste left at campsites.