Tarryall Reservoir is a State Wildlife Area in Park County, Colorado, sitting at 9,000 feet elevation about an hour west of Manitou Springs and the Colorado Springs metro area. The reservoir occupies a high mountain meadow surrounded by pine-covered hills, and a waterfall spills over the dam on one end, creating one of the more picturesque fishing spots along the Front Range. Access requires a State Wildlife Area pass, a valid Colorado fishing license, or a hunting license, so plan ahead before making the drive.
Fishing is the main event at Tarryall Reservoir, and anglers report consistently productive outings. The reservoir is stocked with trout, and catches of decent-to-large pan-size fish are common, with some reviewers describing monster trout on stringers. Pike also inhabit the water, and crayfish traps suggest a healthy crawdad population. Fly fishing works well near the dam, while shore fishing produces results on multiple sides of the reservoir. The inlet side tends to run shallow and weedy, so fishing near the dam yields better results. A fish finder reveals average depths of 15 to 25 feet with plenty of fish showing on screen. Ice fishing draws anglers during winter months when the reservoir freezes over and crowds thin out considerably.
Kayaking and paddleboarding offer relaxing flatwater experiences on Tarryall Reservoir. Multiple put-in points line the shore, and the modest size of the reservoir keeps conditions manageable for all skill levels. Bring sunscreen because shade is nearly nonexistent around the open meadow setting. Wind picks up frequently and can arrive without warning, so an electric trolling motor helps for canoes and small boats navigating choppy conditions. The boat ramp provides easy launch access for trailered watercraft.
Camping at Tarryall Reservoir is limited to two small campgrounds with roughly five sites each, and there is no fee to camp as long as you hold a valid SWA pass or license. Sites sit just off the road with vault toilets nearby but no other services. Dispersed camping in the surrounding national forest provides additional options, though some previously open areas have been closed in recent years, so check current regulations before setting up camp. The back side of the reservoir, away from the main road, offers the most secluded spots.
The drive to Tarryall Reservoir winds through scenic Park County terrain with mountain views and fall color displays that reviewers describe as worth the trip alone. Cell service is poor to nonexistent around the reservoir, so download maps and bring supplies. Nighttime temperatures drop to the low 40s even at the peak of summer, making warm layers essential for overnight stays. Eagle sightings are common near the water, and the birding draws its own dedicated following. The reservoir can get crowded on peak summer weekends despite its remote feel, so arriving early secures the best parking and fishing spots along the shore.