Williams Creek Reservoir is a secluded mountain impoundment in Hinsdale County, tucked away in the San Juan National Forest near Pagosa Springs in southwest Colorado. Reached by a manageable dirt road that standard passenger cars can handle in summer, this reservoir offers the kind of quiet, off-the-beaten-path experience that feels increasingly rare. If you want a Colorado lake where crowds are thin and the scenery looks like a painting, Williams Creek Reservoir delivers.
Fishing is a primary attraction at Williams Creek Reservoir. The lake holds healthy populations of trout, and anglers report excellent results, particularly from a boat. Bank fishing is more challenging, with limited productive shoreline spots compared to boat access. An outlet stream below the reservoir also holds trout and provides an alternative fishing experience. The reservoir is open to kayaks and boats, making it easy to reach deeper water and quieter coves.
A roughly five-mile trail loops around the entire reservoir, providing an easy hike with breathtaking views of the surrounding mountains and water. The trail is mostly straightforward, though a few sections have loose soil requiring careful footing, and at least one stream crossing is necessary to complete the full loop. The trail occasionally splits into multiple paths but always reconnects. Geese and other waterfowl are common on the lake, and visitors have spotted bald eagles catching fish from the reservoir.
Camping is well-established at Williams Creek Reservoir. Designated campground sites are available, including the Teal Campsite, which overlooks the reservoir. Dispersed camping is also permitted throughout the surrounding national forest. Restroom facilities are available at the main access area. Visitors have stayed for extended trips of two weeks, noting the warm water temperatures in summer that allowed for comfortable swimming on multiple days.
The reservoir sits well off the main highway, contributing to a peaceful, uncrowded atmosphere even during the summer season. Fall visits are possible with a four-wheel-drive vehicle, though snow can close the area as early as November. The dirt access road is passable for standard cars in dry summer conditions. The surrounding area near Pagosa Springs offers additional hiking opportunities and scenic drives. Williams Creek Reservoir is best suited for visitors seeking a remote, relaxing getaway with fishing, paddling, and quiet mountain scenery.