Olney Springs Reservoir sits on the eastern plains of Crowley County, a small prairie reservoir near the town of Olney Springs that once served as a local fishing and swimming hole but has fallen into a state of decline. Located at roughly 38.17 degrees north in the lower Arkansas Valley, this reservoir tells a familiar story for many small plains water bodies in Colorado — changing water conditions and reduced maintenance have transformed what was once a community gathering spot into an uncertain destination that requires managing expectations before visiting.
Historically, Olney Springs Reservoir offered fishing and swimming to locals, and Colorado Parks and Wildlife stocking information still references the reservoir. However, recent visitors report that water levels have dropped dramatically, with some finding little to no water at all. The reservoir area is not well maintained, and the infrastructure shows its age. Longtime residents express frustration at the deterioration of what was once a beloved community resource. Anyone planning a fishing trip should check current water conditions before making the drive, as the reservoir may not hold fishable water depending on the season and year.
Finding Olney Springs Reservoir can be a challenge in itself. Multiple maps show incorrect road names — some list Lane 8, others Road D.5, and the actual access follows a canal road. There are no clear signs identifying the reservoir, and the turnoff is easy to miss. A very old, faded sign reading Olney Springs Ponds is tucked back from the road, but blink and you will drive past it. GPS coordinates are your best bet for navigation rather than relying on road names from mapping apps.
Despite the water and maintenance challenges, the area still draws visitors for other reasons. Dog walkers appreciate the open space and quiet surroundings, and the flat terrain around the reservoir provides easy walking paths. The reservoir area has also become popular with ATV and dirt bike riders who use the open ground when water levels are low. The surrounding prairie landscape offers a quiet place to think and decompress away from busier recreation areas. Bird watching along the Arkansas Valley corridor can be productive, with migratory waterfowl and raptors passing through seasonally. Olney Springs Reservoir is best approached as a casual stop for walking or exploring rather than a planned fishing or swimming destination until water conditions and management improve.