Boxelder Reservoir Number Two is a shallow plains reservoir in northern Larimer County, managed by Colorado Parks and Wildlife as part of the Boxelder State Wildlife Area northwest of Fort Collins. Like its sibling Boxelder Reservoir Number Three to the southeast, this reservoir targets anglers looking for quieter, less-developed water where effort and experience determine success.
The reservoir sits in open grassland along the transition from high plains to foothills, with expansive views to the west toward the Rocky Mountain front range. Water depth averages 5 to 10 feet throughout most of the reservoir, with a muddy bottom that supports warmwater species. Northern pike are the headline catch here, and anglers who work weed edges and submerged structure with the right presentations can find solid fish. Bass and panfish also inhabit the reservoir, though catch rates for all species tend to run slow. This is water that rewards anglers who understand structure, have patience, and know how to adapt tactics to murky, shallow conditions.
Access and facilities at Boxelder Reservoir Number Two are basic. A vault toilet and small parking area serve visitors, and a walking path provides shoreline access around the reservoir. There is no boat ramp, but wakeless hand-launched watercraft like kayaks, canoes, and float tubes are permitted and give a significant advantage for reaching fish-holding structure away from the bank. No swimming, picnic tables, or campfires are allowed.
Dogs must stay on leash at all times, though off-leash violations are a common complaint among visitors. Shore fishing is most productive along the south banks, where access to structure is better than other areas. The east side of the reservoir opens up to the best views. Boxelder Reservoir Number Two is best suited for experienced anglers who want a quiet, uncrowded fishery and do not mind minimal amenities in exchange for diverse species and the chance to fish water that most people overlook.